Council on American Islamic Relations
From Silvers
Back to Timely News Items on Islam
Back to The Danish Cartoon Fiasco
Back to Islam syllabus
Contents |
CAIR Alerts and Positions
CAIR Interview detailing their position on other examples of images of Muhammad
Mohammed sculpture at top US court draws mild rebuke from US Muslim leaders
Tue Feb 7, 3:54 PM ET
Amid an international outcry over cartoons of Mohammed, some American Muslim leaders have expressed concern about depictions of the prophet at US public buildings, including the Supreme Court.
At the same time they draw a sharp contrast between the cartoons, which they consider blasphemous and designed to offend, and statues or sculptures meant to honor Mohammed as a historical figure and lawgiver.
"We have expressed the Muslim community's concerns about a variety of images of the Prophet Mohammed, whether it be in textbooks, editorial cartoons or even in the Supreme Court," Ibrahim Hooper, spokesman for the Washington-based Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), told AFP.
The sculpture of the prophet at the country's top court is part of a marble frieze depicting 18 influential lawgivers, including Moses, Confucius and Charlemagne.
The sculpture of Mohammed shows him holding a Koran in his left hand and a sword in his right. The frieze has adorned the courtroom since the building opened in 1935.
Hooper said CAIR in the past has requested that the sculpture be removed, as Islamic tradition forbids any depictions of the prophet. But the court turned down the request, saying that altering the frieze would compromise its artistic integrity.
It agreed, however, to change literature about the sculpture to refer to Mohammed as the "prophet" rather than the "founder" of Islam.
"The court ruled that the good outweighed the bad ... and the community's response was one that was very tempered," said Edina Lekovic, spokeswoman for the Muslim Public Affairs Council in Washington. "They (community leaders) came out and said that they disagreed with the court ruling but they apreciated the thought and the intention behind the sculpture."
Hooper said though Muslim leader still objected to the sculpture it did not "mean we are going to force our views on others."
A statue of Mohammed that stood in the Manhattan Appellate Courthouse in New York was removed in the 1950s following protests by representatives from various Muslim nations.
CAIR in 2001 also succeeded in having a 14th century Persian painting with an image of the Prophet Mohammed removed from a PBS documentary about Islam.
There have also been cases in which US Muslim leaders have succeeded in having images of Mohammed removed from public school textbooks.
Hooper said while depictions of the prophet on public buildings or in textbooks were objectionable, they bore no resemblance to the cartoons first published in a Danish newspaper and which have sparked violent protests in the Muslim world. One of the cartoons shows the prophet wearing a bomb-shaped turban.
"The cartoons were published with the stated intent of incitement and insult," Hooper said.
He pointed to a cartoon that appeared in various US newspapers in 2002 that showed Mohammed driving a truck with a nuclear bomb and a headline that read, "What would Mohammed drive?"
"The stated intent in that instance was political commentary, not to gratuitously insult Muslims," Hooper said. "Intent is a big factor in this whole controversy."
Copyright © 2006 Agence France Presse. All rights reserved. The information contained in the AFP News report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Agence France Presse.
Action Alerts
Help Defend the Image of Prophet Muhammad (response to Danish Cartoons)
Thursday, February 02, 2006
In the Name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful
CAIR ACTION ALERT #486
HELP DEFEND THE IMAGE OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH)
(WASHINGTON, D.C., 2/2/2006) – CAIR today called on imams and khatibs nationwide to offer Friday khutbas focusing on the significance of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) to Muslims worldwide.
That call comes as newspapers in Europe continue to publish intentionally provocative and insulting cartoons of the prophet, and Muslims worldwide express their outrage through boycotts and protests. Some media outlets, such as CNN have made an editorial decision not to show the cartoons.
CNN wrote: “CNN has chosen to not show the cartoons in respect for Islam.” SEE: Storm Grows over Mohammad Cartoons http://edition.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/europe/02/02/cartoons.wrap/
Proposed Outline of Khutbah for Friday February 3, 2006
- What the Prophet Muhammad means to Muslims
- Aspects of the prophet’s personality
- The Messenger and the message
- Ignorance fuels adverse reactions to the prophet’s message
- How the Prophet Muhammad dealt with personal attacks
- Precluding punishment for the people of Taif - Offering kindness to abusive neighbors - Offering amnesty to former enemies in Mecca
- Ignorance can only be countered by education and personal examples of good character
- The prophet’s love, mercy, good manners, and educational approach turned foes into friends
- Turn these defamatory incidents into a learning opportunity.
- Share information about the prophet with your neighbors of other faiths.
Representatives of the CAIR met today with the Norwegian ambassador to the United States to express Muslim concerns about publication in Norway of the cartoons that mocked the Prophet Muhammad.
ACTION REQUESTED:
1. OFFER SERMONS THIS FRIDAY highlighting how the Prophet Muhammad responded to personal attacks with forgiveness and kindness.
2. SCHEDULE PUBLIC EVENTS such as lectures, movies and mosque open houses focusing on the life and message of the Prophet Muhammad.
3. SHARE BOOKS and other materials about the prophet with friends and colleagues of other faiths.
4. BECOME A PERSONAL EXAMPLE of good character as instructed by the Prophet Muhammad.
5. THANK CNN for their decision not to publish the cartoons. Go to: http://edition.cnn.com/feedback/forms/form1.html
- PLEASE ANNOUNCE, POST AND DISTRIBUTE -
CAIR Council on American-Islamic Relations 453 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. Washington, D.C. 20003 Tel: 202-488-8787, 202-744-7726 Fax: 202-488-0833 E-mail: cair@cair-net.org URL: http://www.cair-net.org
